The highlight from a golf standpoint were the two rounds we played at Jack Nicklaus’ Muirfield Village Golf Club, shown above, the home of the Memorial Tournament on the PGA Tour and rated inside the top 30 US courses by every major golf publication. It’s a great track and the conditioning was incredible, especially when you consider how hot it was in the Columbus area, with humidex readings close to 50 degrees Celsius. Thank goodness for the milkshakes in the clubhouse after our round, which are as good as advertised.
Nicklaus’ home course growing up was the Donald Ross-designed Scioto Country Club and what a treat it was to play there. While the course featured few trees upon its opening, Scioto today is a true parkland layout with towering trees bordering most of the holes on a wonderfully undulating property. I was very impressed with Scioto and think it may be a tad underrated, as it sits near the bottom of most top 100 lists for American courses.
The Arthur Hills-designed Longaberger Golf Club was the only public course we played on the trip. It’s rated within the top 100 public courses in the US by all of the publications and I thought it was a strong test but was unimpressed with some of the routing choices. It is an incredible property and I think Hills went for home runs on every hole, perhaps at the expense of the routing. The course is practically unwalkable but I’ll definitely admit there are some great holes out there.
We played two other courses on the trip that aren’t on any ranking lists. Wedgewood G&CC was a pleasant surprise – it’s a lovely Robert Trent Jones Jr design and I really enjoyed the course. Wedgewood is a prototypical parkland country club course, with beautiful trees on a rolling piece of property and I was told that Jones Jr moved a relatively small amount of earth to build the course. I had a lot of fun playing Wedgewood and it definitely was the biggest surprise of the trip, as I knew nothing about the course prior to playing it.
My best score on the trip came at The Medallion Club, a 27-hole private club designed by Nicklaus’ oldest son Jack II. They market the club as having three distinct nines, with one being a parkland, another more links-style and a third that plays through marsh and meadow. It’s a bit of a tale, as all three seem to feature long, unplayable naturalized areas just off the fairways, which tighten the courses considerably. I hit a bunch of knockdown drivers to keep the ball in play and shot a very good 73 (+1) but my partner in crime for the trip, my wife’s uncle Henry, had a much tougher go. He’s about a 15 handicap and was able to break 90 at Muirfield and Longaberger but couldn’t break 100 at Medallion due to all the trouble left and right of the fairways. It’s just too much for a private club in my humble opinion. The club is great, the staff are wonderful and extremely friendly, our hosts were incredibly fun and generous but the course was only average.
Plans to play the Scarlet Course at The Ohio State University last week were scrapped due to a Nationwide Tour event being played. We also were supposed to play either The Golf Club, a Pete Dye design or Double Eagle, both of which are ranked highly in the myriad top 100 lists but games fell through at the last minute due to schedule conflicts. Perhaps another time…
I’ll be writing extensive reviews of Muirfield Village, Scioto and Longaberger sometime in the autumn, as I still have to document my experiences at the four Bandon courses in addition to the five great courses I played in New York State in May.
Putting golf aside for a second, Columbus is a wonderful city and we had a great time on the trip. We stayed in the Easton Town Center, a 1.7-million square foot urban town center featuring pedestrian-friendly streetscapes, open-air gathering spaces, fountains, children’s parks, and more than 170 retail, entertainment and dining establishments. So there were plenty of things to do for my wife, my son and my mother-in-law (and my wife’s aunt) while the guys were playing golf. Outside of Easton, they also spent a day at the Columbus Zoo and another day downtown, taking in the Science Center, among other things. The city is modern, clean and very safe and I can safely say that we’ll be going back again sometime in the future. Gosh, I wish we had a Brio Tuscan Grille in St. Catharines! Great Italian!
My game has been getting better lately but I still haven’t been able to finish rounds this year. Club Championship weekend is only two days away – with about four new guys who carry scratch indexes entering the Open Flight this year and the club making the curious decision to cut down to top 9 and ties in each flight after two days, I had a tough decision to make. You see, I’ve never finished better than 6th overall and last year, despite a very solid first two rounds of 76-76, I still found myself 11 shots back heading into the last day. I’d end up 17 shots back after all was said and done, finishing in a tie for 7th. Even when I played decently, I really can’t compete with the best at our club.
So with my game a bit off this year, I have made the excruciating decision to drop out of the Open Flight and play in A flight instead. As a very competitive person, I can’t tell you how much it upsets me but I have to be a realist – I’m just not a good enough player to go against these college scholarship kids and a couple of the great mid-amateurs at our club.
I’ll have to get ready for some major ribbing from my friends for this decision. Open Flight plays from the tips but the other flights play from the middle tees, something I absolutely detest and I usually end up scoring WORSE even at the shorter yardage.
That all said, at least I’ll have a good chance of being competitive and that’s something I just can’t say if I played Open again this year.